BESTIE ISLAND

Off-off Broadway WORLD PREMIERE of an original pop musical - just a 15-minute subway ride from Times Square! Limited run October 2nd - 11th, 2025.

A missing reality TV contestant. A desperate single mom. Crimes messier than spilled rosé.

BESTIE ISLAND THE MUSICAL serves up your biggest reality obsessions - “The Bachelor,” “Love Island” and “Real Housewives” - set to pop earworms. Follow our heroine Jamie through tropical chaos, messy drama, and crimes she never saw coming. The show is Carly Rae Jepsen meets Little Shop of Horrors meets the darkest corners of your FYP*. Don't miss out -  there will be only seven performances this October at LIC's Court Square theater! 

*For the uninitiated, your FYP is the For You Page on TikTok

The Creators

Music and Lyrics 
Colby Lapolla - work produced with Selling Sunset, Disney, Diane Warren, etc. 

Libretto and Some Lyrics
Sarah Caroline Billings - work produced at Cherry Lane, Barrow Group, American University, etc. 

The Cast

Bringing experience from Broadway tours, the West End, and beyond:

Analia Piloto, Samantha Joy Pearlman*, Emily Lynne Miller*, Mychal Phillips*, Jillian Paige
Luke Hamilton*,  Kierlan Denninger, Brianna Paradiso, Taylor Simon, Jessica Morilak

*Equity Member appearing with permission of Actors’ Equity Association without benefit of an Equity contract in this Off-Off Broadway production. Equity Approved Showcase.

WARNING: Semi-strobe lighting effects used.

This show is not recommended for those under 13.

Click for Trigger Warnings (Contain Spoilers)

If you're seeking an industry comp - please fill out this form!

Court Square Theater is conveniently located just 15 minutes from Times Square.
7, M, E trains at Court Square within a 5-minute walk. 

The venue is an ADA-compliant space.

Issues with your ticket? bestieisland@gmail.com

https://www.bestieislandthemusical.com/

BESTIE ISLAND is a sponsored project of Fractured Atlas, a non-profit arts service organization. Contributions for the charitable purposes of BESTIE ISLAND must be made payable to “Fractured Atlas” only and are tax-deductible to the extent permitted by law.