Skip to main content
  • The Sweetest Crime: A Chocolate Covered Murder Mystery
1 of 3

The Sweetest Crime: A Chocolate Covered Murder Mystery

Multiple dates and times The October Ensemble Theater, 66 S Main St, Ocean Grove, NJ 07756 - THIRD FLOOR

The Sweetest Crime: A Chocolate Covered Murder Mystery

Multiple dates and times The October Ensemble Theater, 66 S Main St, Ocean Grove, NJ 07756 - THIRD FLOOR

A HILARIOUS CHOCOLATE THEMED MURDER MYSTERY!

18+ ONLY | IMMERSIVE | COMEDIC | FOUR WEEKS ONLY!

A hilarious, comedic murder mystery, The Sweetest Crime takes place at a live taping for the struggling game show CHOCOPALOOZA! where talented contestants compete for prizes by sculpting chocolate treats into delicious masterpieces. Tragedy strikes when someone is murdered! Everyone is a suspect, and the audience must use clues from the performance to discover who the murderer is...

Perfect for a Valentine's Night Out! 

STARRING...

  • Jennifer Carlisle as Fanny Fudgebottom
  • Nick St. Onge as Barry Bitters
  • Dakota Reider as "Glaze"
  • Elle River as Honeybelle Buttercream
  • Brandon Gulya as Detective Graham Ganache
  • Eddie Rogers as Chef Coco
  • Reese Towler as Maya Melt
  • Miranda Holland as Fudgebuddy

DATES AND DETAILS:

When: January 29th - February 21st (including Valentine's Day performances!) 

Where: The October Ensemble Theater (66 S. Main Street, Ocean Grove, NJ, Third Floor) - right near downtown Asbury Park!

Running Time: 90 minutes with no intermission

QUESTIONS: Email boxoffice@octoberensemble.com or call 609-607-7861

LIMITED SEATING PER SHOW. GET YOUR TICKETS BEFORE THEY'RE GONE!

Please note this production contains some loud noises and flashing lights. 


FAQ:

How does seating work?

Standard Seating: Theater row seating with a mini table at each pair of seats in our intimate theater. When you place your order, seats will be reserved for you an our hosts will seat you upon arrival. The venue is extremely intimate, so every seat is a fantastic one! If you have multiple separate orders and would like to be seated together, please indicate that in the "are you sitting with another party who has already purchased?" section of the checkout form. Large groups may be split amongst adjacent rows. 

⭐ VIP Seating: The best seats in the house. Guaranteed seating in the front two rows of the audience and the best opportunity to interact with the show. Extremely limited amount per show. 

Are food and beverages provided?

No. Theater concessions (water, chips, candy, soda, etc.) will be available for purchase. Please note, alcohol is not served or permitted at this venue.

I've never heard of this show before. Has it been done before?

The Sweetest Crime is an original hit Murder Mystery Comedy written by esteemed playwright Elle Michael River (Murder, Magic & Mead, Oh Sh*t, Sherlock!) After two sold-out runs in 2024 and 2026, the show is being revived for 4 weeks, better than ever and just in time for Valentine's Day! 

Is this interactive?

Yes! The audience can directly influence the events of the show, and will have the chance to solve the mystery by deciphering clues, interrogating the suspects, and more.


ABOUT THE VENUE & NEARBY DINING

🅿️ PARKING

Free parking is available in the front and back of the building. If those lots fill up, street parking is available within walking distance. Handicap parking spots are available.

♿ SEATING & ACCESSIBILITY:

Seating is traditional theatre row seating with mini-cocktail tables at each pair of seats. Wheelchair seating is available. Please select the option that notes you require a wheelchair seat during checkout.

🍔🍣 NEARBY DINING: ENJOY A MEAL BEFORE OR AFTER THE SHOW!

We're just a short walk (or even shorter drive!) away from Asbury Park, with seemingly limitless restaurants to choose from, such as Moonstruck (5-minute walk), Pascal & Sabine (10-minute walk), Taka (5-minute walk), and more. While there are too many options to list them all here, peruse just a few of the best nearby restaurants according to Tripadvisor by clicking here. Don't forget to grab your tickets first! 



Refund & Transfer Policy

All sales are final. Transfers to a different show may be offered on a case-by-case basis depending on availability. If you have any questions, please email info@octoberensemble.com.