Skip to main content
  • The Gathering House Murder Mystery Dinners
  • The Gathering House Murder Mystery Dinners
  • The Gathering House Murder Mystery Dinners
  • The Gathering House Murder Mystery Dinners
1 of 3

The Gathering House Murder Mystery Dinners

Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:00 PM - Thu Apr 22, 2027 10:30 PM 10582 Mulligan Dr, Wheatfield, IN, 46392

The Gathering House Murder Mystery Dinners

Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:00 PM - Thu Apr 22, 2027 10:30 PM 10582 Mulligan Dr, Wheatfield, IN, 46392

Step into a Night of Intrigue, Suspicion, and Fine Dining...

Join us for The Gathering House Murder Mystery Dinners, an immersive evening of live entertainment, interactive storytelling, and a delicious dinner experience. Hosted by The Murder Mystery Co., the nationally known Murder Mystery Party Game Experts as seen on Shark Tank, this is not just a show...it’s a mystery you’re part of.

From the moment you arrive, you’ll be swept into a world of secrets, hidden motives, and unexpected twists. Enjoy a lively cocktail hour, then sit down for dinner as the mystery unfolds around you. Question suspects, uncover clues, and see if you can solve the crime before the final reveal.

Event Details

  • Ticket Price: $100 per person
    Includes dinner, one drink ticket, and the live Murder Mystery show
    Purchase all 4 events at once and get a 10% discount!
  • Capacity: Limited to 40 guests per event
  • Bar: Cash bar available
  • Age Requirement: 21 and over
  • Location: The Gathering House
  • Parking: Available at the Driving Range

Schedule

  • Cocktail Hour begins at 6:15 PM
  • Show & Dinner begin at 7:15 PM
  • Showtime ends and awards distributed at 9:15 PM

Whether you come dressed to impress, ready to play detective, or just looking for a memorable night out, this is an evening designed to entertain, surprise, and delight. Dressing up is not required, but is more fun! Tickets are limited and expected to sell quickly...reserve your seat before the mystery is sold out.

Contact Lisa Herma with questions: 219-987-3611, option 2

Themes

A Dance With Death / Thursday, November 19th

A 1950's Sock Hop Gone Sour

This 1950’s prom is a doo wop disaster! When a death on the dance floor makes this prom night a party foul, it is up to you to figure out whodunit and get this dance back on track. Trade clues with your guests, gather information about the crime, and reveal the punk that made this prom nowheresville. This night of laughter and dancing is now too heavy to razz anyone’s berries, so it’s up to you to find the murderer!

Word from the bird is this is one show you will not want to miss. This night is shootin’ to be swell despite the disaster. Ladies, bows and pins in your hair will go nicely with your puffy sleeved prom gowns. Gents, you will look sharp in white and black suits or tuxes. Get ready to put on your thinking caps; you’ll need your wits about you to solve this crime.


Best Laid Plans / Thursday, January 21st

AN OLD HOLLYWOOD WHODUNNIT

Come to the quintessential whodunnit thriller at the estate of Sir Warren Peace and get thrown into a night of mystery, intrigue, and murder you will never forget. With a killer crowd of people just waiting for murder to arrive on the scene, this night will keep everyone looking over their shoulders and guessing who the next victim will be! Bribe suspects for clues and gather information to uncover the unhinged guest who is whacking all the invitees. Just be careful, because you could be next! Dress your best in evening wear and suits—this is a refined party, after all.

I Love the 80's to Death / Thursday, March 18th

A Rockin' Radical Night of Mystery

It’s the 80’s again, and all of the big names are here for a big concert. Tensions run rampant as backstage secrets spill out into the spotlight with like, totally tragic results! This isn’t an episode of Miami Vice! This is like…murder. It’s up to you to bust it like a ghost, for sure! Peg your jeans, slouch your socks, flash some neon, put on way too much eyeliner and get that hair up! You are going to solve this crime in style. No time to be Too Shy! You are a Smooth Operator, and you know to listen to those Careless Whispers. It’s time to put on your Sunglasses at Night and Relax. Time after time…You will solve the case.

Til Death Do Us Part / Thursday, April 22nd

All is Fair in Love and Murder

The birds are chirping, the sun is shining, but the wedding bells aren’t ringing for this not-so-happy couple when a member of the wedding party is murdered! With a raging bridezilla and an unenthused groom on the scene, it may be happily never after in this nuptial nightmare. Trade clues with your guests and help the hapless couple figure out whodunnit so they can say I do before the wedding hour passes them by!

The bride and groom aren’t picky, so you can wear just about whatever you’d like. In fact, we encourage you to wear your own wedding dress or the most ridiculous wedding attire you can come up with. It’ll make their special day that much more special, so long as they actually get the chance to walk down the aisle!

Refund Policy

All ticket sales are final...No refunds will be issued. Tickets may be transferred to another person, but only for the same scheduled show..

Contact Lisa Herma with questions: 219-987-3611, option 2

Location

10582 Mulligan Dr, Wheatfield, IN, 46392